Shifts in Marketing Department Expenditures Reveals Changes In Tactics During Recession

According to the 2021 edition of CBRE’s Trends^® in the Hotel Industry report, total operating revenue for the average hotel in the sample declined by 62.2 percent from 2019 to 2020. This is by far the greatest decline in revenue recorded during the 84-year history of the Trends^® survey. For reference purposes, operating revenues declined by 18.4 percent during the Great Recession in 2009.

Hotel sales and marketing department expenditures can be viewed as an investment to obtain revenue. However, facing such extreme reductions in revenues, the marketing department, like all others, was tasked in 2020 with the mandate to cut costs. A review of the changes in marketing department expenditures from 2019 to 2020 provides some interesting insights into how U.S. hotels adjusted their unit-level marketing tactics in response to the industry recession.

To assess how U.S. hotel sales and marketing executives altered their plans in response to the dramatic fall-off in performance, we have examined the sales and marketing department expenses of a same-store sample of 4,028 properties during the years 2019 and 2020. The study sample consisted solely of hotels that have on-site sales and marketing personnel. In aggregate, the properties averaged 214 rooms in size, with a 2020 occupancy of 34.9%, and an average daily rate (ADR) of $144.48. This is down from an occupancy of 74.9% in 2019, along with and ADR of $184.03.

All Expenses Reduced

CBRE’s Trends^® in the Hotel Industry survey tracks 15 different expense categories within the Sales and Marketing Department. These include seven labor related costs, three franchisee related fees, and five specific marketing expenditure categories.

From 2019 to 2020, the average property in our study sample cut their marketing department expenditures by 53.1 percent. For reference purposes, the aggregate of all hotel undistributed department expenses declined by 39.8 percent during the year. With revenues declining by 64.1 percent at these same hotels, sales and marketing department expenses as a percent of total revenue increased from 9.2 percent in 2019 to 11.9 in 2020.

Within the sales and marketing department, franchise related fees comprise the biggest percentage of total department costs. In 2019, franchise related fees averaged 48.8 percent of total department costs. Since most franchise fees are typically charged as a percent of rooms revenue, the 63.3 percent decline in rooms revenue for the study sample triggered a 58.2 percent decline in franchise fee payments. The precipitous drop in franchise fees is the primary reason why marketing department expenditures declined to a greater degree than the other undistributed departments.

Labor costs are the second largest expense within the sales and marketing department. In 2019, the combined cost for salaries, wages and employee benefits equaled 28.5 percent of total department costs. From 2019 to 2020, these costs were cut by 44.9 percent. Among the various labor related costs tracked by CBRE within the sales and marketing department, the greatest percentage declines were observed among the salaries and wages paid to non-management personnel, service charge payouts, and bonuses.

Being the largest hotel operating expense, labor cuts were made throughout all departments within a hotel during 2020. As we saw in other departments, the impact within the sales and marketing department was felt more among non-management employees (87% decline in salaries and wages) versus management personnel (37.9%). Sales department employees are frequently incentivized with bonus payments based on achieving designated revenue targets. Therefore, with total revenues down by 64.1 percent, it is not surprising that incentive payments to sales personnel fell by 90.8 percent.

Significant cuts were also made to the public relations budgets during 2020. Public relations expenses include the provision of goods and services used to promote the property in the community and the industry. This includes promotional expenditures such as entry fees to events held by civic groups, sponsoring gift certificates for non-profit organizations, participation in charity golf tournaments, and client appreciation parties. Given the gratis nature of these costs, they were one of the earliest items to be cut from hotel budgets.

The two sales and marketing expense categories that saw the least reduction on a percentage basis during 2020 were advertising and website. It should be noted that the advertising cost category includes ads placed on websites and social media. Apparently the relative efficiency of reaching consumers via the internet was deemed to be a relatively cost effective expenditure during the year.

Differences Across Property Types

Among the various property types, the percentage declines in sales and marketing dollars were greatest at full-service and convention hotels. These property types typically have the greatest number of on-site sales personnel, plus suffered the greatest declines in revenues and associated franchise fees. Although the cuts in sales and marketing department expenses were greatest at these two property types on a per-available-room basis, sales and marketing department costs measured on a per-occupied-room basis went up. This is emblematic of relatively large declines in occupancy suffered by these property type categories.

The one property type in our study sample that posted an increase in sales and marketing department expenditures from 2019 to 2020 were resort hotels. As the summer of 2020 began to unfold, it quickly became evident that remote resort locations were preferred by travelers seeking to get away from the house and travel to a less dense location where they can maintain social distancing. During 2020, the resort hotels in our sample suffered an occupancy decline of 58.1 percent, but were able to enjoy an ADR increase of 5.0 percent. Given the rise in marketing dollars, but decline in occupied rooms, sales and marketing department expenditures measured on a per-occupied-room basis declined by 46.5 percent during the year. While the increased marketing efforts did not appear to sustain occupancy levels on an annual basis, they did result in capturing guests willing to pay the premium for lower density levels. As a result, resort hotels were able to achieve profit margin levels stronger than seen in the past.

Will Marketing Investments Return?

A big question on the mind of hotel owners and operators is which of the many cost control measures implemented in 2020 will be sustained in the future. Despite rising levels of revenue, through June of 2021 CBRE’s sample of monthly hotel operating statements suggest that sales and marketing department expenditures are still on the decline for most of the property types that typically have on-site sales personnel. This does not come as a surprise given the magnitude of profit declines observed in 2020 while the 2021 budgets were being prepared. With U.S. hotel demand forecast to return to pre-COVID levels by the end of 2023, hotel owners and operators will want to make sure their assets are competing aggressively for their share of travelers. This can only be accomplished with the efficient use of increased sales and marketing expenditures.

Robert Mandelbaum
Director of Research Information Services
CBRE Hotels